The Republican consultant class keeps blaming candidates and cash for a wipeout that left gloating Democrats holding both chambers.
The voters who skipped the polls tell a different story.
And Reince Priebus told Trey Gowdy one thing about those voters his old party never wanted to hear.
Reince Priebus Admitted the Party and the Base Don’t Share an Address
Gowdy didn’t waste any time on Sunday Night in America. He asked Priebus what happened in the November midterms and whether anything could have softened the blow.
Priebus has held just about every job the Republican machine offers. He chaired the Wisconsin Republican Party, ran the Republican National Committee for six years, and served as Donald Trump’s first White House Chief of Staff.
He knows a thing or two about comebacks, too. Priebus reminded viewers that he inherited an RNC buried $26 million in debt. “I took a second mortgage out on my house to make the first payroll,” he said.
Then he delivered the line that ought to hang on the wall of every GOP consulting shop in Washington, DC.
“Number one, Trump voters are not Republican voters,” Priebus said. “That’s number one, and we’ve become a midterm party that can’t win and a presidential party that can’t lose.”
He used his home state as Exhibit A. Priebus said the total Republican vote in Wisconsin in 2026 looked almost identical to the 2022 total. But Ron Johnson held his Senate seat in 2022, and this time Republicans took a beating.
“We are turning out voters that are not our voters,” Priebus said. “We might be turning out what we think are Trump voters, but they weren’t buying what we were selling.”
Give the man credit. Most party lifers would sooner blame the weather.
A Third of Trump’s Coalition Never Left the House
And the data backs him up, then some.
Pollster J.L. Partners surveyed 1,000 registered voters on Election Day and checked the results against more than 30,000 interviews from the campaign. The firm found that 35 percent of Trump’s 2024 voters never cast a midterm ballot at all. Only 8 percent crossed over to the Democrats.
By the firm’s math, the no-shows account for 10 points of the 15-point swing toward Democrats since 2024. Party switchers supplied the other five.
Now look at who stayed home. Among Trump’s 2024 voters, 46 percent of those without a college degree skipped the midterms, along with 44 percent of voters over 65 and 39 percent of rural voters.
Those are the farmers, the plant workers, and the retirees who carried Trump back to the White House. Only 22 percent of Kamala Harris voters sat this one out.
But midterm drop-off is nothing new, and the long view makes the picture uglier. Trump pulled nearly 63 million votes in 2016, and Republicans drew 50.5 million in 2018. Trump won 74.2 million in 2020, and the party managed 54.2 million in 2022. Trump hit 77.3 million in 2024, and Republicans slid to roughly 50.1 million this November.
Run those numbers yourself. The falloff grows every cycle, from about 20 percent to 27 percent to 35 percent.
Democrats would love to call the result a love letter to their agenda. Their own voters won’t sign it. Half of Democrat voters in the J.L. Partners survey called their ballot a rebuke of the administration rather than an endorsement of Democrat policies, and only 16 percent want another crack at impeaching Trump.
Hakeem Jeffries and his incoming committee chairmen are sharpening their subpoena pens anyway. And that small slice of Trump voters who did flip? They viewed the DSA favorably, 44 percent to 27 percent. That’s the crowd the Left now plans to build a majority around.
The Autopsy Priebus Commissioned Told the Base to Get Lost
Here’s the chapter Priebus skipped.
In March 2013, the RNC under his leadership released the Growth and Opportunity Project, the famous post-Romney “autopsy.” The authors insisted the committee didn’t make policy, then carved out one exception: “we must embrace and champion comprehensive immigration reform.”
Everybody inside the Beltway knew what that phrase meant. Amnesty for illegal aliens, wrapped in a consultant’s bow. The Senate passed its Gang of Eight bill that summer, and only stubborn House conservatives and a furious grassroots kept it from becoming law.
The authors tacked on a warning, too. “If we do not, our party’s appeal will continue to shrink to its core constituencies only,” they wrote.
Read that again next to the J.L. Partners numbers. The autopsy treated the core as a ceiling the party had to break through. It turned out to be the whole ballgame, and the GOP brand still can’t get those voters off the couch without Trump’s name on the ballot.
Then came October 2016. According to multiple published accounts, including Bob Woodward’s book Fear, Priebus told Trump after the Access Hollywood tape surfaced that he should drop out or face a historic landslide. Priebus later called separate reports of a plot to put Mike Pence at the top of the ticket “100% false.”
Trump stayed in and won anyway. About six months into his presidency, he replaced Priebus with John Kelly and announced the switch on Twitter.
So the man who once bet against the Trump voter now explains the Trump voter on national television. And this time, he’s mostly right.
Trump’s Voters Can Tell the Man From the Brand
The harder question is why those voters show up for Trump and ghost the party.
Start with who they are. They’re populist nationalist conservatives first and Republicans a distant second. They want the border sealed, American paychecks protected, and American troops out of other countries’ fights.
They’ll crawl over broken glass for a man who brawls with the press and the Democrats. They won’t lift a finger for a brand they watched cut amnesty deals, wave through trade pacts that shipped factories overseas, and send their sons to the Middle East for a generation.
The midterm exit polling makes the foreign policy piece tough to wave away. Nearly two out of every three voters told pollsters the US made the wrong call in taking military action against Iran, a war the neoconservative wing pushed for years. Even among those skeptics, 15 percent still voted Republican, a sign the doubts ran right through the GOP’s own coalition.
Maybe that’s too tidy. Cost of living and gas prices topped the worry list in the J.L. Partners survey, and no single war explains a 15-point swing.
But a voter who already distrusts the party doesn’t need a dozen reasons to stay home. He needs one. The neocons handed him a big one, and the consultant class kept mailing him glossy flyers about “outreach.”
Priebus even offered a second lesson that proves the point. He said Republicans dumped “$200 million to $250 million into Texas,” which left the party with no money edge anywhere else.
He didn’t mention who lit the first match. The March primary in Texas broke state spending records, led by a colossal ad blitz for John Cornyn, the incumbent who helped write Joe Biden’s 2022 gun control law. The base sent Cornyn packing in the runoff anyway, and the general election became a money pit that still handed the Left a Texas Senate seat for the first time since 1988.
And the bill for that establishment bonfire landed on every other Republican in the country.
Expect the consultants to commission another autopsy soon. Expect it to call for softer messaging, more outreach, and maybe another round of “comprehensive” something. Expect the donor class to applaud.
But the voters who stayed home this November already read the last one. Whoever carries the America First banner once Trump leaves the stage, JD Vance or anybody else, inherits a coalition that trusts the man more than the party.
The 2013 autopsy warned that Republicans would shrink to their core constituencies unless they championed comprehensive immigration reform. In November 2026, more than a third of that core stayed home rather than vote for the party that wrote it.
Sources:
Breitbart, “Priebus: ‘Trump Voters Are Not Republican Voters,’” Jeff Poor, November 9, 2026
Fox News, “Trump voters are not Republican voters: Reince Priebus,” Sunday Night in America with Trey Gowdy, November 9, 2026
Townhall, “A New Analysis Has a Troubling Explanation for the Republican Midterm Wipeout,” Dmitri Bolt, November 17, 2026 (citing J.L. Partners and the New York Post)
Yahoo News, “Poll: 35% of Trump Voters Skipped Midterms,” November 2026
CNN, “RNC autopsy progress report,” January 23, 2014
NBC News, “GOP report calls for sweeping reforms to compete in 2016,” March 18, 2013
MPR News, “After party ‘autopsy,’ GOP touts progress,” March 18, 2014
The Week, “Reince Priebus reportedly advised Donald Trump to drop out of the race after leaked audio tape,” December 2016
The Hill, “Pence told RNC he could replace Trump on ticket after ‘Access Hollywood’ tape came out: report,” December 2017
Business Insider, “Mike Pence and Reince Priebus reportedly planned a coup to replace Trump after the ‘Access Hollywood’ tape,” December 5, 2017
Bob Woodward, Fear: Trump in the White House, 2018
KSAT, “Here’s what we learned from the action-packed Texas primaries,” March 4, 2026
WJLA/KEYE, “Talarico wins Texas Senate race, first statewide Democratic victory in over 30 years,” November 2026
IBTimes UK, “James Talarico Defeats Ken Paxton in Texas Senate Race,” November 2026